Are Composting Tumblers Worth It

Are Composting Tumblers Worth It?

As someone who spends a good portion of their free time with their hands in the dirt and smoke in the air from my grill, I’ve always been fascinated by the process of composting. It’s like Mother Nature’s magic trick: taking organic waste and transforming it into a nutrient-rich soil that makes my homegrown vegetables taste all the better.

Composting has been around for centuries, a time-tested method for reducing waste and enriching soil. Traditionally, it involved piling up organic matter in a corner of the garden and letting nature do its work. Yet, as my interest grew, and as I delved deeper into the composting community, I found out about a new player in the game: the compost tumbler.

A more modern tool for an age-old practice, compost tumblers promised quicker composting, less mess, and a more manageable process. Yet, as with any newer, “improved” version of a classic, it was met with both acclaim and criticism. This left me, and many others, pondering: “Are composting tumblers worth it?”

As a dedicated composter and outdoor grilling enthusiast, I decided to dive into this debate. In my quest, I’ve considered various factors, from user experiences to environmental impact, and even tested out a few models myself. This article is a culmination of that exploration and an attempt to answer that burning question, not just for me, but for anyone looking to contribute to our planet’s health through composting. Let’s dig in, shall we?


What Are Composting Tumblers?

Now, if you’re new to the world of composting, you might be wondering, “What exactly is a composting tumbler?” As an outdoor grilling enthusiast with a deep love for gardening and composting, I’m thrilled to introduce you to this innovative tool.

Essentially, a composting tumbler is a closed system, a container designed to hold and, importantly, easily turn your compost. If you’re picturing something similar to a lottery ball machine, you’re not far off! These devices vary greatly in terms of size and design, with options suitable for a petite urban balcony garden to those capable of handling the composting needs of sprawling rural acreages.

The hallmark of a composting tumbler is its ability to tumble, or rotate. This feature is designed to simplify the process of mixing and aerating the compost. Remember the age-old advice of turning your compost pile now and then with a pitchfork or shovel? With a composting tumbler, a turn or two of the handle, and you’re done!

You see, compared to traditional composting methods—like a compost heap or bin—composting tumblers aim to streamline the process. They keep your composting materials neatly contained, saving you from the potential mess of a free-standing pile. Plus, their closed design can also help deter pests, a common concern when composting.

What to Put in a Compost Tumbler to Start?

Starting a compost tumbler isn’t much of a Herculean task; it’s like creating a balanced meal, but for microorganisms. I often get asked, “What should I put in my compost tumbler to kick-start the composting process?” Well, the secret to a healthy compost pile lies in the balance of “greens” and “browns” – the two major components of compost.

“Greens,” as I like to call them, are your nitrogen-rich organic materials. Think of things like your kitchen scraps – fruit and vegetable peels, coffee grounds, and tea bags. When I’m cooking, I often keep a small bin beside me to collect these scraps. Even freshly cut grass and garden clippings fall into this category. Greens are high in nitrogen and provide the protein that the microbes in your compost pile need to grow and multiply.

On the other hand, “browns” are the carbon-rich materials that supply energy to these microbes. I usually add dry leaves, twigs, paper, and cardboard, which are excellent sources of carbon. If you’re a fan of online shopping like me, you probably have a ton of cardboard boxes lying around. Rather than tossing them in the trash, use them in your compost!

What Not to Put in a Compost Tumbler?

As an outdoor grilling enthusiast and an avid composter, I’ve discovered that knowing what not to put in your compost tumbler is just as important as knowing what to put in. I’ve had my fair share of composting missteps, so I’m here to help you avoid some common composting pitfalls.

First and foremost, meat, fish, and dairy products are a big no-no for most backyard composting systems. While technically these items can decompose, they tend to attract pests and can cause unpleasant odors. Trust me, the last thing you want is to open your compost tumbler and be greeted by a swarm of flies or an uninvited critter.

The same goes for pet waste, particularly from dogs and cats. Pet feces can contain harmful parasites and pathogens that can linger even after the composting process, posing a health risk for anyone handling the compost. As much as I love my furry friends, their waste is better off disposed of in a safe and responsible manner, not in the compost tumbler.

Why Do You Compost in a Tumbler?

Ah, the million-dollar question – “Why do I compost in a tumbler?”

As an outdoor grilling enthusiast and gardening fan, my journey with composting started a few years back. I began with a simple pile in the corner of my backyard. However, the longer I composted, the more I began to see the benefits of using a compost tumbler.

For one, a compost tumbler offers convenience. Unlike the compost pile that required constant turning with a pitchfork (quite a workout, if you ask me), the tumbler only needs a simple spin. Plus, it’s raised off the ground, which saves my back from unnecessary bending.

Then, there’s the speed. Composting in a tumbler is much faster than traditional pile composting. Because the tumbler allows for easy aeration and better heat retention, the composting process is significantly accelerated. In a pile, compost could take up to a year to fully decompose. However, with my tumbler, I can have rich, ready-to-use compost in as little as a few weeks.

What are the Benefits of Composting?

What are the Benefits of Composting?

Ah, composting! Ever since I embarked on this adventure, it’s been a game-changer for my garden and my outlook on waste. So, what are the benefits that make composting so worthwhile?

First off, composting is a remarkable way to recycle kitchen and yard waste. As someone who enjoys outdoor grilling and cooking, I generate a significant amount of organic waste. Rather than sending it off to the landfill, composting allows me to convert this waste into a valuable resource for my garden. In essence, composting has changed my perspective on waste; it’s not just trash anymore, but potential compost material!

Beyond just waste management, composting is incredibly beneficial for gardening and soil health. When I started adding compost to my garden, I noticed a significant improvement in the health and vigor of my plants. Compost enriches the soil, providing a wide range of essential nutrients that plants need to thrive. Plus, it improves soil structure and water retention, making it easier for plant roots to access nutrients.

In addition to boosting plant health, composting also helps combat climate change. How so? Simply put, when organic refuse breaks down within the confines of a landfill, it produces methane, an exceptionally powerful greenhouse gas. By composting, I’m reducing methane emissions and contributing to the fight against global warming. Knowing that my little backyard activity can have such a significant impact is incredibly rewarding!

How Long Do Compost Tumblers Take?

One of the most frequent questions I get asked as a seasoned composter and outdoor grilling enthusiast is – “How long do compost tumblers take?” It’s a valid query, especially for folks looking to get into composting and weighing their options.

The answer, however, is not a simple, fixed number of days or weeks. The composting process in a tumbler can vary significantly depending on a few key factors, which I’ve come to understand through my own trial and error.

Firstly, the composting process depends on the balance of greens and browns you include. Materials rich in nitrogen, often referred to as “greens,” encompass the scraps from fruits and veggies, the remnants of your morning coffee, and clippings from your freshly mowed lawn. Conversely, the group classified as “browns” are abundant in carbon and include elements like desiccated leaves, straw, and torn pieces of newspaper. Ideally, you want to maintain a 2:1 ratio of browns to greens. If the balance is right, you could have compost ready in as little as 2-4 weeks.

Temperature is another significant factor. The composting process speeds up with heat. This is why compost tumblers can make compost quicker than traditional piles – they can retain heat better. During the warm summer months, my tumbler works at warp speed, breaking down materials much faster than in cooler seasons.

The dimensions of the components you’re composting significantly influence the process. The pace at which the composting material decomposes is directly proportional to its size; Importantly, the rate at which items transform into compost is faster when the pieces are smaller in size. Before I toss in my kitchen scraps, I chop them up into smaller bits. It’s an extra step, but it definitely shaves off time from the composting process.

The Best Compost Tumblers

Advantages of Composting Tumblers

As I embarked on my journey through the world of composting tumblers, I found several advantages that could sway any composting enthusiast towards making the investment. So, let me share these benefits, speaking from my own experience and perspective.

First and foremost, composting tumblers offer a certain level of speed that traditional compost heaps simply can’t compete with. Owing to their efficient design that promotes effective aeration and heat retention, these tumblers can fast-track the composting process, turning your kitchen scraps and yard waste into black gold in as little as two to eight weeks. It’s quite satisfying, let me tell you, to watch your organic waste transform so rapidly into nutrient-rich compost.

On the user-friendly front, composting tumblers score high. Gone are the days of wielding a heavy pitchfork or shovel to turn a massive compost heap. With a compost tumbler, all you have to do is give it a few turns now and then. It’s easy, it’s quick, and it requires far less manual labor. Trust me, your back will thank you.

Disadvantages of Composting Tumblers

While the advantages of composting tumblers are indeed appealing, it wouldn’t be fair to make a decision without addressing their potential shortcomings. As I navigated my way through this new composting terrain, I bumped into a few obstacles that might make you think twice before rushing to purchase one.

The first concern that jumped out at me was the price tag. Composting tumblers tend to be more expensive than traditional compost bins or heaps. Sure, the sleek design, convenience, and speedy composting process are tempting, but are they worth the additional cost? That’s a question only you can answer, depending on your composting needs and budget.

Next, while composting tumblers can handle a variety of organic waste, I found that they’re not as all-embracing as a regular compost heap. There are certain limitations on what you can compost in them. Materials that take a longer time to break down, like branches or corn cobs, might not be suitable for a compost tumbler. You might need to be more selective with your compost ingredients, which could be a bit of a hassle if you’re used to chucking everything into a compost pile.

Another potential disadvantage is volume. While there are larger models available, the capacity of most composting tumblers doesn’t match up to that of a traditional compost heap or bin. If you have a larger garden or generate a lot of kitchen waste, you might find that a compost tumbler fills up rather quickly, leaving you with a backlog of organic waste.

Finally, getting the hang of a compost tumbler might involve a bit of a learning curve. It’s not just about throwing in your organic waste and turning the handle occasionally. You’ll need to get the balance of green and brown materials right, ensure adequate moisture levels, and regularly turn the unit for effective aeration. The process, while not overly complicated, does require a certain level of understanding and attention to detail.

Environmental Impact

Let’s now turn our attention to the environmental aspect of , a consideration close to my heart. Composting itself is inherently eco-friendly, and compost tumblers are no exception. They play a significant role in reducing organic waste, turning it into valuable compost rather than sending it to landfill. The impact of this cannot be overstated—it’s a practical, tangible way for us to reduce our individual carbon footprints6.

However, when I consider an item’s environmental credentials, I like to take a holistic view. This means looking beyond its obvious functionality and considering its entire lifecycle—from creation to disposal.

Composting tumblers, like any manufactured product, have a manufacturing process. The materials used to make them—typically plastics or metals—are sourced, processed, and shaped into the final product. This process consumes resources and energy, and often involves greenhouse gas emissions.

Then, there’s the usage phase, which, in the case of composting tumblers, is pretty green. They’re helping us recycle organic waste and enrich our soils—two big ticks for environmental sustainability. But it’s worth remembering that some composting tumblers may have plastic parts that could degrade over time, particularly if they’re exposed to harsh weather conditions. The durability of your chosen tumbler, therefore, plays a part in its environmental impact.

Finally, at the end of its life, a compost tumbler must be disposed of. While some parts may be recyclable, others may not. Depending on its components, a compost tumbler could end up contributing to landfill waste.

Taking all this into account, I believe composting tumblers, while having distinct environmental advantages, also have an environmental cost. As with all things, it’s about balance. The benefits of using a composting tumbler—particularly in terms of waste reduction—may well outweigh the costs of its lifecycle. This is a personal judgment each of us must make.

Now, let’s move on to some product recommendations. Whether you’re sold on compost tumblers or still weighing your options, it’s good to know which models are getting the best reviews.


Best Composting Tumblers (Product Recommendation)

Absolutely, I’m all in for a little window shopping! Let me tell you about some of my top picks for composting tumblers that I genuinely believe could make a world of difference in your composting journey.

Best Overall: FCMP Outdoor IM4000 Tumbling Composter

Best Overall FCMP Outdoor IM4000 Tumbling ComposterThis one has caught my eye more than once. The FCMP Outdoor IM4000 Tumbling Composter has a 37-gallon capacity and a nifty dual-chamber design. This means you can fill one chamber while the other one is doing the composting magic. How handy is that? It’s also extremely well-ventilated, which is a major plus. It’s an easy one to turn, even when fully loaded. It might be a bit pricier than a simple compost bin, but for the ease and speed of composting, I find it absolutely worth the investment.

Best Budget Option Miracle-Gro Small ComposterBest Budget Option: Miracle-Gro Small Composter

Money doesn’t grow on trees, does it? And as someone who appreciates a good budget-friendly find, the Miracle-Gro Small Composter has really impressed me. Despite its smaller size, with an 18.5-gallon capacity, it is surprisingly mighty when it comes to churning out rich compost. It’s perfect for smaller gardens or if you’re just starting out with composting.

Best for Large Gardens Joraform Compost Tumbler JK 270Best for Large Gardens: Joraform Compost Tumbler JK 270

If you’ve got a larger garden or are serious about your composting, then I recommend taking a look at the Joraform Compost Tumbler JK 270. It boasts a substantial 70-gallon capacity and a robust construction that’s built to last. Its well-insulated design keeps the heat in, which accelerates the composting process. I’ve found it really lives up to the needs of a large garden.

Most Eco-Friendly Option Envirocycle The Most Beautiful Composter in The WorldMost Eco-Friendly Option: Envirocycle The Most Beautiful Composter in The World

If you’re as passionate about environmental consciousness as I am, you’ll love the Envirocycle Composter. It’s a BPA-free, 35-gallon composter that prides itself on being as beautiful as it is functional. What sets it apart is its ability to produce both solid and liquid compost – it’s like a two-for-one deal! Plus, it’s pretty compact and could be a great addition to any patio or balcony.

Tips for Using a Composting Tumbler

Every day I go out to my compost tumbler, there’s something so satisfying about turning the handle and knowing that I’m turning my kitchen scraps and yard waste into black gold – nutrient-rich compost for my garden. Over the years, I’ve learned a thing or two about how to get the most out of my composting tumbler, and I’m eager to share those tips with you.

1. Master the Composting Recipe

Composting isn’t just about tossing in whatever organic waste you have lying around. It’s more like baking a cake – you need the right balance of ingredients. In composting, these ingredients are ‘green’ and ‘brown’ materials. Greens are nitrogen-rich materials like vegetable scraps, coffee grounds, and fresh grass clippings. Browns, on the other hand, are carbon-rich materials like dead leaves, cardboard, and straw. I’ve found that a ratio of about 2:1 of browns to greens generally produces a healthy compost.

2. Make it a Routine

Like many things in life, consistency is key when it comes to composting. I make it a routine to turn my compost tumbler at least once every two to three days. The turning process helps aerate the compost and speeds up the breakdown process. Remember, your compost needs to breathe, too!

3. Monitor the Moisture

If there’s one thing I’ve learned in my composting journey, it’s that too much or too little moisture can stall the composting process. The dampness of your compost heap should be comparable to that of a thoroughly squeezed sponge. If it’s too dry, add some green material or a bit of water. If it’s too wet, add more brown material to help absorb the excess moisture.

4. Keep an Eye Out for Troubles

No matter how much care we put into our compost, sometimes things can go awry. If you notice your compost has a foul smell, it might be too wet, not getting enough air, or it might have too much green material. Adjust accordingly. Trust me, your nose will thank you!

5. Remember Patience is a Virtue

Even with a composting tumbler, composting is a process that can’t be rushed. Depending on your materials and environmental conditions, it might take anywhere from a few weeks to a couple of months to get finished compost. But believe me, when you finally spread that beautiful, nutrient-rich compost in your garden, all that waiting will be worth it.

Compost tumbler


After embarking on this composting journey, I’ve realized that the question of whether a composting tumbler is worth the investment isn’t a one-size-fits-all answer. It truly depends on your unique needs, budget, and dedication to creating a more sustainable world.

Composting tumblers are an excellent tool for many. They speed up the composting process, make it easier and more convenient, and provide a neat, tidy solution that can fit comfortably into small spaces. When I first got my compost tumbler, I marveled at how simple it was to turn the handle and watch my kitchen scraps and yard waste transform into nutrient-rich soil.

But there are considerations to weigh. For those who are budget-conscious, the upfront cost of composting tumblers may be a hurdle. Learning to use them effectively does come with a bit of a learning curve and you’ll need to be aware of what you can and cannot compost in these devices.

In my experience, I’ve found that each composting journey is unique, and the right tools for the journey depend on the gardener. Ultimately, whether you choose to use a composting tumbler, a compost heap, or another method, remember that the goal is to reduce waste and return nutrients back to the Earth.

There’s a certain magic to composting. It’s the cycle of life in action – a transformation from waste to wealth. Whether it happens in a tumbler, a bin, or a pile, composting is a tangible step towards a more sustainable planet, one that benefits not just your garden, but the entire Earth. So, let’s keep the magic going, one compost pile at a time.


What to put in the compost tumbler to start?
You can start by adding a balanced mix of green and brown materials.

What not to put in a compost tumbler?
Avoid composting meat, dairy, and diseased plants as they can attract pests and cause foul odors.

Why do you compost in a tumbler?
Composting in a tumbler can be faster, easier, and more hygienic than traditional methods.

What are the benefits of composting?
Composting reduces waste, enriches soil, and can help mitigate climate change.

How long do compost tumblers take?
The composting process in tumblers can range from two to eight weeks, depending on the materials and conditions.

Similar Posts

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *